Sunday, September 16, 2018
Judicial Deference in Competition Law
11 October 2018, University of Warsaw, Krakowskie Przedmieście 32, Pałac Tyszkiewiczów-Potockich.
It is crucial for contemporary democracies to respond efficiently to economic and social challenges. A major role in this respect is played by administrative authorities, to whom a legislator delegates the responsibility to design and implement policies in areas that require expert knowledge, such as financial markets’ supervision, sectorial regulation in energy and telecommunication, or the protection of competition. The challenge is to build such a system that administrative authorities can undertake their tasks efficiently while guaranteeing at the same that their activities are subject to controls. An adequate shape of judicial review is crucial here. On one hand, it is necessary for the courts to play their traditional role, namely to protect the lawfulness of administrative actions and individual rights. On the other hand, one can presume that courts should not replace expert administrative authorities in the fulfilment of the tasks delegated to the later by the legislator. Against this backdrop, the conference· aims to discuss the place for judicial deference in an area of law that requires expert knowledge and involves policy questions, namely competition law.
9:00-9:10 Opening of the Conference
9:10-9:20 Introductory remarks
Maciej Bernatt, University of Warsaw
9:20-10:00 Key Note Speech
Paul Craig, Oxford University, Explaining the Foundations of Judicial Deference
10:00-11:30 Judicial Deference: General Aspects
Rob Widdershoven, University of Utrecht, Judicial Deference and the Court of Justice
Kent H. Barnett, University of Georgia, U.S., Current Debates in Deference to U.S. Administrative Agencies
Miroslava Scholten, University of Utrecht, Judicial Deference from a Broader Perspective on Controls in the System of the Rule of Law
Chair: Professor Mirosław Wyrzykowski, Judge Emeritus, Constitutional Tribunal of Poland
11:45-13:30 Judicial Deference and Competition Authorities’ Economic Assessment
Ioannis Lianos, University College London, Judicial scrutiny of economic evidence and the direction of deference
Andriani Kalintiri, City University of London, The review of the European Commission’s economic assessments by the General Court
Heike Schweitzer, Free University Berlin, Intensity of Judicial Review of Competition Authorities Economic Assessment. German Perspective
Chair: Małgorzata Modzelewska de Raad, Modzelewska&Pasnik Law Firm
14:30-16:15 Judicial Deference and Competition Authorities Fining Policy
Krystyna Kowalik-Bańczyk, Judge of the General Court, Intensity of Judicial Review of Fines in EU Competition Law
Dawid Miąsik, Judge of Polish Supreme Court, Intensity of Judicial Review of Fines in Poland
Csongor Nagy, Szeged University, Judicial Review of Fines in Hungarian Competition Law
Chair: Iwona Terlecka, Clifford Chance
16:30-18:20 Institutional Structure of Competition Authority and the Intensity of Judicial Review
Renato Nazzini, King’s College London, The European Commission’s Institutional Structure and the Intensity of Judicial Review
Katalin Cseres, University of Amsterdam, The Role of Consumers in Competition Proceedings and its Implication for Judicial Review
Maciej Bernatt, University of Warsaw, The Intensity of Judicial Review and the Competition Authority Institutional Structure, Findings from Central Europe, EU and the U.S.
David George, UK Competition and Market Authority, The Intensity of Judicial Review by CAT and the Institutional Model of UK Competition Law
Chair: Bernadeta Kasztelan-Świetlik, Gessel law firm, former vice-President of Polish Competition Authority
18:20-18:40 Summary of the Conference
Address by Spencer Waller, Loyola University Chicago
Conference is supported by:
- The conference fee to be paid at the time of enrolment. Transfer description must include your full name along with phrase ‘CARS JUDICIAL DEFERENCE CONFERENCE’. Account details: Fundacja na rzecz Wydzialu Zarzadzania UW, IBAN: PL 07 1240 2887 1111 0000 3388 7461. SWIFT: PKOPPLPW. The reduced fee applies to academics, judges, public officials/administration employees. It is fully waived in case of Phd candidates and students.
- The conference is organised in the framework of the research project ‘The Limits of Judicial Assessment in Competition Law’ (Polish National Science Centre, UMO-2014/15/D/HS5/01562).